Missed Deadlines, Lost Claims: How to Build a Claims Response Calendar That Holds Up

Unemployment wage audits are state reviews that compare the unemployment benefits a claimant received with the wages employers reported, to catch payments that shouldn’t have been made. For employers, a timely and accurate response helps protect your unemployment tax rate and keeps you compliant with audits many states require.

The stakes are rising. In April 2026, the U.S. Government Accountability Office reported that the Federal-State Unemployment Insurance program had an estimated $5.6 billion in improper payments in fiscal year 2025, resulting in an improper payment rate of 14.9% that is well above the 10% threshold federal law sets for program compliance.

Improper payments happen for many reasons, including identity fraud, eligibility fraud, and simple errors. Whatever the cause, wage audits are one of the main ways states find and correct them, so benefits go to the right people in the right amounts.

Key Takeaways

  • Unemployment wage audits compare benefits paid with employer-reported wages to find improper payments.
  • States use three main types: Benefit Accuracy Measurement (BAM) audits, new hire audits, and quarterly wage crossmatches.
  • Timely, accurate responses can remove improper benefit charges from your account and help protect your unemployment tax rate. Some audits are mandatory.
  • The U.S. Department of Labor made fraud prevention and recovery of improper payments its top unemployment insurance priority for fiscal year 2027, so employers should expect more wage audit requests.

What Is an Unemployment Wage Audit?

In a wage audit, the state reviews a claimant’s reported income, employment history, and other details to confirm benefits went to the right person in the right amount.

These reviews protect state unemployment funds, correct errors made when a claim was first processed, and flag fraudulent claims.

Your response won’t change the original separation decision, but it helps the state find improper payments. If the state finds an overpayment or fraud, that can lower the charges against your account.

Types of Unemployment Wage Audits

State unemployment agencies review unemployment claims to ensure compliance with state regulations and to protect against potential fraud. States use three main types of wage audits, each with its own purpose.

Benefit Accuracy Measurement (BAM) Audits

Each week, states randomly select a sample of claims for a Benefit Accuracy Measurement (BAM) audit, a detailed review that measures how accurately unemployment benefits were paid and helps detect both errors and fraud.

New Hire Audits

New hire audits start when a state matches unemployment payments against the National Directory of New Hires and state new hire records. The state is checking whether benefits kept going after the claimant started a new job.

Quarterly Wage Crossmatch Audits

Each quarter, states compare unemployment payments with the wages employers report on quarterly contribution reports, to find weeks when a claimant collected benefits while earning wages.

Why Wage Audits Matter for Your Unemployment Tax Rate

For employers, accurate and timely wage audit responses can help protect your tax rate, which is determined in part by the benefit charges levied against your account. When an audit uncovers improper or fraudulent payments, the related benefit charges can be credited back to your account, so they won’t count against you when the state calculates your tax rate. For more ways to manage your rate, see 6 Ways to Mitigate UI Tax Exposure.

Some audits are also mandatory under state and federal rules, and missing a response can result in penalties and fines.

Why Wage Audits Are Increasing

In September 2026, the U.S. Department of Labor issued Unemployment Insurance Program Letter (UIPL) 14-26, which sets state priorities for fiscal year 2027. The first priority is proactively identifying and preventing fraud and recovering improper payments, based on model national standards the department announced in July 2026.

Several of those standards point directly to more wage verification. States are asked to check continued claims against state and interstate wage records and new hire directories, confirm separation details directly with employers, and treat BAM reviews as a minimum rather than a maximum. The guidance also encourages states to collect more detailed wage information and to move toward employer wage reporting at least monthly.

For employers, that likely means more audit requests and less tolerance for late responses. The department also reminded states that employers with a pattern of late or incomplete responses to state information requests can’t receive relief from benefit charges.

How Thomas & Company Handles Wage Audits

Wage audits are part of our fully managed Employment and Wage Verification service, so audit requests come off your plate with no HR lift required. Our team works as an extension of your HR and payroll departments, backed by more than 30 years of experience and a 99% client retention rate.

"I love that Thomas & Company can handle all of the wage audits for us...knowing that you are handling these saves us a ton of time."

Same-Day Mail Processing

All mail is received and processed the same day it arrives. Documents move immediately into an internal workflow for timely processing. All physical documents are secured and never leave our office until they are shredded on site.

Audits Completed Within 5 Business Days

All wage audits are completed within 5 business days of receipt. Our dedicated wage audit team communicates with each state to keep you compliant, resolving any differences between state requirements and your data.

State Follow-Up

Thomas & Company also acts as an intermediary between our clients and the state, answering the state’s wage audit questions and assisting with any follow-up. We stay with each audit until the state’s questions are resolved.

"Thomas & Company has contacts at the state that help me get answers!"

Get Help With Unemployment Wage Audits

Our wage audit team works as an extension of your HR and payroll departments, from same-day mail processing through follow-up with the state. Talk to our team about taking wage audits off your plate.

Frequently Asked Questions About Wage Audits

What is an unemployment wage audit?

An unemployment wage audit is a state review that compares unemployment benefits paid to a claimant with the wages employers reported, to find overpayments, underpayments, and fraud.

Do employers have to respond to wage audits?

Many states require employers to respond to certain wage audits, and missing a response can lead to penalties or fines. Requirements and deadlines vary by state.

How do wage audits affect my unemployment tax rate?

When an audit uncovers improper or fraudulent payments, the related benefit charges can be credited back to your account, so they no longer count against you when the state calculates your tax rate.

What is a BAM audit?

A Benefit Accuracy Measurement (BAM) audit is a detailed review of a randomly selected claim that states use each week to measure how accurately unemployment benefits are being paid.

How quickly does Thomas & Company complete wage audits?

Thomas & Company completes every wage audit within five business days of receipt and processes incoming mail the same day it arrives.